durusmail: mems-talk: 3D vs 2D MEMS
3D vs 2D MEMS
2004-07-22
Surface Smoothness
2004-07-22
2004-07-26
2004-07-22
3D vs 2D MEMS
Borski, Justin
2004-07-22
Linas,
You might find resources discussing it on University sites, like this paper:
http://www.engineering.cornell.edu/engrc350/ingenuity/Tung_MF_issue_1.pdf


Those terms, 2D and 3D MEMS, in my mind refer only to optical switching
products.  Generally, a MEMS device by default will be a "3D" structure, of
course.  There are many types of applications of MEMS, I think the term "3D
MEMS" is clic lingo only in the optical product space.

So, referring to optical switches, the 2D variety will generally be limited
by die size which in turn limits number of inputs and outputs (eg, 8x8,
16x16).  It also becomes limited by the optical path length through air from
input lens, to the mirror, back to an output lens, since the light path is
being sent "in 2 dimensions", or planar to the die surface.  2D switches are
also generally cheaper and simpler to build than 3D systems.

The 3D optical switches are different in that their input optical paths come
in "at any angle" down to a focused location, where mirror arrays re-direct
back to another, separate "any angle" location.  The device is therefore
operating in 3 dimensions of space.

- Justin

Justin C. Borski
MEMS Program Manager
Advanced MicroSensors Inc.
jborski@advancedmicrosensors.com



-----Original Message-----
From: Jauniskis, Linas [mailto:ljauniskis@foster-miller.com]
Sent: Wednesday, July 21, 2004 3:36 PM
To: mems-talk@memsnet.org
Subject: [mems-talk] 3D vs 2D MEMS


I am doing some background research and haven't found a clear explanation of
the design difference between 2D and 3D MEMS.

Can anyone offer an explanation or provide a link with one?

Thanks,
L.
_______________________________________________
MEMS-talk@memsnet.org mailing list: to unsubscribe or change your list
options, visit http://mail.mems-exchange.org/mailman/listinfo/mems-talk
Hosted by the MEMS Exchange, providers of MEMS processing services.
Visit us at http://www.memsnet.org/

**********************AMS CONFIDENTIAL AND PROPRIETARY
INFORMATION*****************************
This e-mail communication and any attachments are confidential and intended only
for the use of the designated recipients named above.



reply